• If you are having problems logging in please use the Contact Us in the lower right hand corner of the forum page for assistance.

A Notre Dame Law Professor Says:

Mike

Well-known member
I suggest no conclusion as to whether Obama is eligible or not. But the citizens whom the media and political pundits dismiss as “birthers” have raised legitimate questions. That legitimacy is fueled by Obama’s curious, even bizarre, refusal to consent to the release of the relevant records. Perhaps there is nothing to the issues raised. Or perhaps there is. This is potentially serious business. If it turns out that Obama knew he was ineligible when he campaigned and when he took the oath as President, it could be the biggest political fraud in the history of the world. As long as Obama refuses to disclose the records, speculation will grow and grow without any necessary relation to the truth. The first step toward resolving the issue is full discovery and disclosure of the facts.

The courts are not the only entities empowered to deal with such a question. A committee of the House of Representatives could be authorized to conduct an investigation into the eligibility issue. It is difficult to imagine, to borrow [Woodrow] Wilson’s phrase, a more pressing “affair of government” than the question of whether a sitting President obtained his office illegally, and perhaps even by fraud. An investigating body must not prejudge the case. Its concern must be, first, to put the facts on the record and then to consider whatever legislation or other remedy might be appropriate in light of those facts.

The House of Representatives is an appropriate body to inquire into the facts and legal implications of a President’s disputed eligibility for the office. [..] The power to investigate can be exercised by a House committee provided that the investigation is within that committee’s authorization as determined by the House. An investigation into Obama’s eligibility by a committee or subcommittee of the House could have several legitimate objectives, including among others:

1. To ascertain the facts, compelling by subpoena the production of all the available records relevant to Obama’s eligibility, including the complete Hawaiian records of his birth; his passport records to ascertain whether he traveled to Pakistan in 1981 on an American or other passport; the records from Occidental College, Columbia University and Harvard Law School to determine whether Obama described himself as a foreign student; and such other records as may be relevant. The disclosure of such information to the public would be an appropriate exercise of Congress’ “informing function.”

2. The consideration of legislation to require candidates for a federal elective office to produce, at an appropriate time, evidence of their eligibility for that office. There is now no federal law or regulation that requires such disclosure.

3. The consideration of legislation to define the constitutional term, “a natural born Citizen.”

The American people do not know whether the current President achieved election by misrepresenting, innocently or by fraud, his eligibility for that office. I neither know nor suggest the answer to that question. But it would be a public service for the House of Representatives to employ its authority to determine those facts and to recommend any indicated changes in the law or the Constitution.
 

Steve

Well-known member
it doesn't have to be done at the federal level,,

states can enact laws to do the same, and more.


2. The consideration of legislation to require candidates for a federal elective office to produce, at an appropriate time, evidence of their eligibility for that office. There is now no federal law or regulation that requires such disclosure.

3. The consideration of legislation to define the constitutional term, “a natural born Citizen.”

both could be done at the state level, challenged by the courts and verified by the Supreme courts by 2012..
 

Tam

Well-known member
I agree with the good Professor the question will not go away even if Obama wishes on a falling star, it is only going to grow bigger if he doesn't clear the air by showing his sealed records. But the thing is I doubt Obama wants it to go away as it seems everytime he needs a distraction from the issue at hand his Birth Certificate issue surfaces.

The issue of the government shutting down due to the Dems unwillingness to cut spending and what is the Liberal Bias Media asking Republicans about? if they support the Birthers claims. :roll:

HAPPILY The unintended consequences to Obama's actions is the States feeling they need to define the rules of which a candidate can be added to their State Ballots. WHICH SHOULD HAVE BEEN DONE YEARS AGO. If the Dems fight the law asking to provide proof all the way to the Supreme Court then one has to wonder WHY and WHAT THEY ARE HOPING TO HIDE BY DOING SO?
 
Top