• If you are having problems logging in please use the Contact Us in the lower right hand corner of the forum page for assistance.

check off advertising

Red Robin

Well-known member
I don't like to have my money in advertisements directed toward me. Tell the checkoff people to drop the tag at the end of their ads that say "this ad paid with check off dollars."
I don't like my government advertising their services back to their tax base.
In either case it is there just to keep someone's job with my money.
 

mrj

Well-known member
Red Robin, would you care to clarify your gripes with the checkoff? I will be seeing some Beef Board members in a couple of weeks and will ask about your points.

Are you referring to the few ads aimed specifically at producers to inform us how the checkoff money is being used? Those ads, and the tag line both are mandated by the law creating the Beef Checkoff, or the rules of operation.

Or could it be that you are part of the target audience for checkoff funded beef ads, that is age 25 to 54 and various subgroups of that age group?

What, exactly, do you mean by "to keep someone's job with my money"?

If you would like to make your points directly with the CBB, you could email [email protected]

mrj
 

Red Robin

Well-known member
mrj said:
Red Robin, would you care to clarify your gripes with the checkoff? I will be seeing some Beef Board members in a couple of weeks and will ask about your points.

Are you referring to the few ads aimed specifically at producers to inform us how the checkoff money is being used? Those ads, and the tag line both are mandated by the law creating the Beef Checkoff, or the rules of operation.

Or could it be that you are part of the target audience for checkoff funded beef ads, that is age 25 to 54 and various subgroups of that age group?

What, exactly, do you mean by "to keep someone's job with my money"?

If you would like to make your points directly with the CBB, you could email [email protected]

mrj
MRJ I was referencing a beef ad aimed at the general public I heard on the radio. The 5 or so second tag at the end of the ad said that this ad was paid for with beef checkoff dollars. Do the end users (consumers) really care how the ad was funded? I suspect that the ad was tagged to please those of us that pay the funds...to show us that our money is working. That in turn is to paint the check off funds in a positive light therefore garnering support for a checkoff increase (which I am not against). I just dislike when any organization uses money raised to raise money. It's not the intended use of the money. It was a small spot in the ad but it could have been used for selling beef.
 

RobertMac

Well-known member
Red Robin said:
mrj said:
Red Robin, would you care to clarify your gripes with the checkoff? I will be seeing some Beef Board members in a couple of weeks and will ask about your points.

Are you referring to the few ads aimed specifically at producers to inform us how the checkoff money is being used? Those ads, and the tag line both are mandated by the law creating the Beef Checkoff, or the rules of operation.

Or could it be that you are part of the target audience for checkoff funded beef ads, that is age 25 to 54 and various subgroups of that age group?

What, exactly, do you mean by "to keep someone's job with my money"?

If you would like to make your points directly with the CBB, you could email [email protected]

mrj
MRJ I was referencing a beef ad aimed at the general public I heard on the radio. The 5 or so second tag at the end of the ad said that this ad was paid for with beef checkoff dollars. Do the end users (consumers) really care how the ad was funded? I suspect that the ad was tagged to please those of us that pay the funds...to show us that our money is working. That in turn is to paint the check off funds in a positive light therefore garnering support for a checkoff increase (which I am not against). I just dislike when any organization uses money raised to raise money. It's not the intended use of the money. It was a small spot in the ad but it could have been used for selling beef.

RR, you mean self promoting like this....

Producer Survey: Majority of Dairy Producers Approve
of Beef Checkoff Program

CENTENNIAL, Colo. (Feb. 27, 2007) — While milk may be their No. 1 commodity, a notable 68 percent of dairy producers surveyed said they approve of the $1-per-head beef checkoff program they contribute to as beef producers, according to recent independent research of dairy producers commissioned by the Cattlemen’s Beef Promotion and Research Board.

This level is similar to the 70 percent of beef producers surveyed who said they approved of the beef checkoff. Additionally, 66 percent of dairy producers surveyed said they were informed about The Beef Checkoff Program, with 21 percent of those saying they were “very well informed” about it.

“Nearly a quarter of the beef supply in the United States comes from dairy beef. That’s why the beef checkoff considers dairy producers an important segment of the beef industry,” said Cattlemen’s Beef Board member Jenny Senn, a dairy producer from Silverstreet, S.C. “It’s encouraging to see from the latest survey results that so many dairy producers approve of their beef checkoff investment, and are informed about where that money is going and the type of programs their checkoff dollars support.”

The dairy industry is well represented on the Cattlemen’s Beef Board, with 15 dairy producers sitting on the board that administers all national checkoff-funded programs. Dairy producers’ investment into the beef checkoff funds six different areas —promotion, research, consumer information, industry information, foreign marketing and producer communications. Beef checkoff programs such as nutrition research and youth initiatives help build demand by educating consumers about the lean and nutrient-rich qualities of beef.

A recent example is a checkoff-funded on-pack nutrition labeling test project in the Midwest that showed consumers are more likely to shop at stores that featured nutrition-labeled meat. Indiana’s Marsh Supermarkets Inc. held a 16-week project to test consumers’ responses to fresh meat nutrition labeling in the meat case. The beef labels emphasized beef as a good source of Zinc, Iron, protein and many B-vitamins. The percentage of consumers who said they believed beef was healthier than they’d previously thought jumped 45 percent following the nutrition-labeling project. Beef dollar sales increased by four to six points at participating retail stores.

Another important program that helps build beef demand by reaching out to younger consumers is the checkoff’s youth education initiative. In the past 10 years, the checkoff has invested nearly $2.5 million in classroom programs to reach more than 25 million children with information about beef nutrition. The checkoff’s latest education project is Choose Well — a school curriculum kit mailed last summer to 10,000 teachers across the nation to help them teach fourth and fifth graders about “power foods” such as beef.

“Dairy producers are often so busy with milk production that they tend to overlook the fact that they are also beef producers,” Senn said. “It’s important for them to understand how their beef checkoff investment is funding research and consumer programs that help build demand for dairy beef.”

The survey, conducted by Aspen Media & Market Research, examined attitudes of 1,225 U.S. beef, dairy and veal producers nationwide. The Beef Board conducts producer surveys regularly to gauge producers’ economic moods and their expectations of checkoff investments, as well as checkoff program familiarity, strengths or weaknesses. The bi-annual surveys are funded with checkoff monies. The results are presented at summer and winter cattle industry conferences.
 

mrj

Well-known member
Guys, it is a fact that most of the problems the Beef Checkoff has encountered, with the POSSIBLE exception of the LMA fight to end it, have been due to producers' lack of knowledge of how the program is run.

Too many producers do not even know that it is CATTLE PRODUCERS who make the decisions at both state and national levels.

A small percentage of the money is mandated to be spent informing cattle producers how the money is used and soliciting their feedback.

Check it out at www.beefboard.org.

They will also listen to your ideas and opinions. Who knows, you might have a valuable idea that will spur huge increases in the demand for beef!

mrj
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
They will also listen to your ideas and opinions. Who knows, you might have a valuable idea that will spur huge increases in the demand for beef!

mrj

92% of the checkoff (tax) payers told the USDA that they wanted all or part of their checkoff dollar used to promote USA BEEF- born, raised and slaughtered.... But neither CBB or USDA or NCBA have made much for moves to bring this about...

So much for listening to the taxpayers....
 

mrj

Well-known member
OT, that the CATTLE PRODUCERS making those decisions do not advertise "born, bred, raised in USA BEEF" at this time, does not mean that they are not listening. The process for changing the rules to make that possible,, and addressing the fact that it isn't necessarily easy to find GUARANTEED born, bred, USA beef MIGHT be reasons it isn't yet accomplished.

Personally, my opinion is that is just so much bogus blame against the CBB. Advertising as currently done by the Beef Checkoff does not exclude your born, raised, USA beef. It leaves some discretion to the consumer and to the market place.

Further, it will create problems when a consumer gets USA raised beef that is not satisfactory, whether in taste, tenderness, or what have you. You are making implied claims that such beef, with no other criteria, is a superior product, and that simply is not true of every piece of USA raised beef that is sold.

Why not leave it up to the market place to 'vote' their money on how/if they want beef labeled. There are enough brands now to show that some do prefer it, and when enough do, the amount of labeled beef will be coming on the market.

Of course, if those consumers do want it labeled not only with country of origin, but traceable back to the ranch or origin with rfid tags/info, your old brand won't cut it, and yours will go on the commodity market anyway.

mrj
 

Tex

Well-known member
mrj said:
OT, that the CATTLE PRODUCERS making those decisions do not advertise "born, bred, raised in USA BEEF" at this time, does not mean that they are not listening. The process for changing the rules to make that possible,, and addressing the fact that it isn't necessarily easy to find GUARANTEED born, bred, USA beef MIGHT be reasons it isn't yet accomplished.

Personally, my opinion is that is just so much bogus blame against the CBB. Advertising as currently done by the Beef Checkoff does not exclude your born, raised, USA beef. It leaves some discretion to the consumer and to the market place.

Tex:So the decision makers of the checkoff are getting hung up on a definition? If they are that incompetent, why trust them with the decision?

Further, it will create problems when a consumer gets USA raised beef that is not satisfactory, whether in taste, tenderness, or what have you. You are making implied claims that such beef, with no other criteria, is a superior product, and that simply is not true of every piece of USA raised beef that is sold.

TexWouldn't you have the same problem with ANY beef advertising? You are just for commodity beef, admit it.:

Why not leave it up to the market place to 'vote' their money on how/if they want beef labeled. There are enough brands now to show that some do prefer it, and when enough do, the amount of labeled beef will be coming on the market.

Tex:It is the checkoff payer's money that is being controlled against their wishes, mrj. People who want to brand in addition to the USA claim of fact can still do so. They are not limited. Checkoff dollars should be spent on producers who are paying for it, and if that means competing with foreign beef for the claim, so be it. When will you ever put your efforts in supporting the producers who pay for the checkoff? All you can come up with is talking points the importers/globalists want.


Of course, if those consumers do want it labeled not only with country of origin, but traceable back to the ranch or origin with rfid tags/info, your old brand won't cut it, and yours will go on the commodity market anyway.

mrj

Tex: mrj, are you trying to limit someone's ability to marke their cattle here?
 

Sandhusker

Well-known member
MRJ, "OT, that the CATTLE PRODUCERS making those decisions do not advertise "born, bred, raised in USA BEEF" at this time, does not mean that they are not listening. The process for changing the rules to make that possible,, and addressing the fact that it isn't necessarily easy to find GUARANTEED born, bred, USA beef MIGHT be reasons it isn't yet accomplished."

What will the excuse be once COOL is implemented?
 
Top