• If you are having problems logging in please use the Contact Us in the lower right hand corner of the forum page for assistance.

"I Told You So".... Wall Street Journal

Mike

Well-known member
July 8, 2009, 3:51 PM ET Mean Street: Human Nature and the Coming Failure of Obamanomics
This is my “told you so” column. Truth is — I was saving it for later in the summer when the Office of Management and Budget revises its deficit figures and reveals just how badly Obamanomics is faring.

But in the last few days, the president and vice-president have been confessing the administration’s failings on the economy to the world’s media, so I’ve had to hurry things along.


So here it is: I told you so.

I told you the president should have focused 100% of his energies on the economy.

I told you the president’s housing plan wouldn’t work out.

I told you that all the class warfare involving taxing the wealthy would hurt consumer spending.

I told you that in spite of the stimulus, unemployment was heading way higher than forecasts.

And I told you that the Obama budget was a fibbers’ delight — and that the White House would eventually be forced to fess up to its Pollyannish forecasts.

And, of course, that’s exactly what is happening right now.

President Obama claims he had “incomplete information.” And in Vice-President Biden’s words, “The truth is, we and everyone else misread the economy.”

Poor Mr. Biden. He can’t even get his truth right.

“Everyone else?”

Not me. And as much I would like to claim some special gift for prognostication, I can’t. There were hundreds of commentators, economists and politicians who were questioning Obamanomics from the very beginning. Just recall the Cato Institute full page-ad from February that warned against the stimulus. Or read through the dozens of cautionary WSJ op-ed pieces published since January.

Now, the White House will try to cover up its failures with the artful language of technocrats. We had incomplete information. Our models didn’t work the way they were supposed to. It would have been even worse had we done nothing.

But that’s obfuscating mumbo-jumbo. It’s the logic and language of career number-crunchers, who believe an economy can be distilled into a giant input-output model. Just read the Council of Economic Advisers papers on the stimulus package.

Obama’s promise of creating 3.5 or 4 million new jobs by year-end 2010 is in essence no more than a mathematical formula. Spend X amount of money and you get Y number of new jobs.

But the White House didn’t just get the formula wrong. It made the mistake of thinking the formula mattered. Capitalism just doesn’t work that way.

And herein lies the real shortcoming of Obamanomics. It is an invention of academics and bureaucrats. And it takes little account of human behavior — how individuals and businesses operate in the real economy.

As I tried to illustrate in my columns, the economy is the sum of billions of individual decisions. Should I modify my mortgage or walk away? Should I buy the car or wait until I really need a new one? Should I fire more staff or take a hit to this quarter’s earnings?

Our behavior may be unpredictable, but it’s not that complicated. Individuals fight to protect their own interests. Businesses fight to protect their profits. That’s what we do — and what we’re supposed to do.

So why did the White House believe that new income and capital gains taxes on the wealthy would keep them spending and investing?

Why did the White House believe that removing overseas tax shelters and raising energy prices would make CEOs keen to bring on new hires?

And why did the White House believe its angry class warfare rhetoric would unite rich and poor, the CEO and worker, the employed and unemployed in our shared goal to grow the economy?

It’s too early to write the obituary for Obamanomics, but when measured against the White House’s own expectations on saving homes, creating jobs and running deficits, it’s clear Obamanomics is falling well short.

The White House shouldn’t blame “everyone else” or “incomplete information.” The coming failure of Obamanomics rests with the Obama administration and human nature itself.
 

Tam

Well-known member
Biden is out tell the media that another Stimulus package is needed already because they misread how bad the economy was. Wasn't he and his boss telling us that the economy was the worst since the Great Depression? :? How much worse could it have been? :shock: Could it possibably be growing worse because of the Administrations SPEND SPEND SPENDING habits?

Wasn't it said many times that the economy would correct itself faster if the government did nothing. Looks like all those reports were right but leave it to Biden to toss more money in the burning barrel and see if that fixes the mess. :roll:

Obama's pick for Vice President has got to put a big question mark on his judgement even for the Liberals :roll:

Then you have to add his judgement on his person associations with people like Blago, Wright, Ayers and Rezko

Add again the Tax Cheats he appointed to Government Departments Geithner, Daschle, Killefer, Sebelius, Solis and Kirk

Then you have Bill Richardson under investigation for a federal pay-to-play scam.

What kind of judgement does Obama have? :? :???: :roll:
 

aplusmnt

Well-known member
Tam said:
Biden is out tell the media that another Stimulus package is needed already because they misread how bad the economy was. Wasn't he and his boss telling us that the economy was the worst since the Great Depression? :? How much worse could it have been?

Good point!

Economy is no way as bad as when they were crying about how it was the worse it has been since the Depression. But they were claiming it was so that meant they realized how bad it was. They just have not been doing anything to make it better, everything they keep doing will only make it worse.

Obama is like a kid in the Candy story with spending, when he should be saving money.

If Obama was smart he would put health care and other big spending issues on back burner. Fix the economy be a hero get elected a second term and then go after all his entitlement programs.

But liberals are so scared if they do not get all they want now then they will never get it!
 
Top