• If you are having problems logging in please use the Contact Us in the lower right hand corner of the forum page for assistance.

Johanns - No more subsidies

Oldtimer said:
I heard an interesting one on the radio the other day- North Dakota Wheat Farmers have been challenging the Canadian subsidized wheat dumping in the US for years ...Last month they won the challenge and the judges ruled against the Canadian Wheat Board- but now the Canadian Government is going to pay the millions in court costs that Canadian Wheat Board spent :???: Is that subsidizing the subsidy :lol:

The radio announcer went on to report that the North Dakota wheat farmers were on their own as far as court costs and that no government entity was going to pick their costs up......


What a load of bs. The North Dakota morons lost that battle. The duties on Canadian wheat were ruled to be illegal. Unless the "judge" you're referring to is another crook like Cebull.
And the Canadian government is not paying the farmers legal costs.
Is it commonplace for americans to be pathalogical liars, first r-calf, now this?
 
Sandhusker..........Explain your Farm Credit statement????
"Anybody with a Farm Credit loan is getting a subsidy."??????
 
MRJ said:
Boys, relax! I heard Bush and Johanns as saying to other nations (Europe in particluar) which pay large subsidies, that the US will cut out subsidies WHEN or AFTER every nation does the same.

BMR, where in the USA have you known of anyone to be turned away from hospitals for needed medical care? I believe anyone can get medical care if they want/need it and the hospitals have to make up the loss on those of us who pay, and pay and PAY! Add to that our additional taxes for the government mandated medical programs!

MRJ


If the above is true why are so many Americans upset that we have scocialized medical care. Sounds like you have it for some in the US but don't treat everyone fairly. Why do so many Americans want to tear down Canad's system ? Is your system better? If we had to pay for all care would some Canadians not be going to the US and tying up your system more. I have seen it both ways as my kids were born in the US, and we have doctored some as it was the closest hospital.
 
Big Muddy rancher said:
MRJ said:
Boys, relax! I heard Bush and Johanns as saying to other nations (Europe in particluar) which pay large subsidies, that the US will cut out subsidies WHEN or AFTER every nation does the same.

BMR, where in the USA have you known of anyone to be turned away from hospitals for needed medical care? I believe anyone can get medical care if they want/need it and the hospitals have to make up the loss on those of us who pay, and pay and PAY! Add to that our additional taxes for the government mandated medical programs!

MRJ


If the above is true why are so many Americans upset that we have scocialized medical care. Sounds like you have it for some in the US but don't treat everyone fairly. Why do so many Americans want to tear down Canad's system ? Is your system better? If we had to pay for all care would some Canadians not be going to the US and tying up your system more. I have seen it both ways as my kids were born in the US, and we have doctored some as it was the closest hospital.

If you own nothing and have nothing- then you get get all the care you want for nothing...They will not turn anyone away for emergency care- but if you don't have insurance to cover it they will send the dogs (credit collection agencies) after you to pay up afterwards... Some people have lost their farms and ranchs while doctoring a family member-- many doctoring decisions are not made on what the doctor advises, but rather on can we afford it- or will it bankrupt us....... :cry:
 
Oldtimer said:
Big Muddy rancher said:
MRJ said:
Boys, relax! I heard Bush and Johanns as saying to other nations (Europe in particluar) which pay large subsidies, that the US will cut out subsidies WHEN or AFTER every nation does the same.

BMR, where in the USA have you known of anyone to be turned away from hospitals for needed medical care? I believe anyone can get medical care if they want/need it and the hospitals have to make up the loss on those of us who pay, and pay and PAY! Add to that our additional taxes for the government mandated medical programs!

MRJ


If the above is true why are so many Americans upset that we have scocialized medical care. Sounds like you have it for some in the US but don't treat everyone fairly. Why do so many Americans want to tear down Canad's system ? Is your system better? If we had to pay for all care would some Canadians not be going to the US and tying up your system more. I have seen it both ways as my kids were born in the US, and we have doctored some as it was the closest hospital.

If you own nothing and have nothing- then you get get all the care you want for nothing...They will not turn anyone away for emergency care- but if you don't have insurance to cover it they will send the dogs (credit collection agencies) after you to pay up afterwards... Some people have lost their farms and ranchs while doctoring a family member-- many doctoring decisions are not made on what the doctor advises, but rather on can we afford it- or will it bankrupt us....... :cry:


And this is better than in Canada? Why would you not want what we have instead of critizing us for have it. Could it be jealousy?
 
Sandhusker said:
Jason said:
Sandhusker said:
Anybody with a Farm Credit loan is getting a subsidy.

Another lie, those loans are just the same as through any bank. Farm credit has to make a profit, just not the huge profits banks make. Interest is charged at market rates and payments are due on regular schedules. The only benefit to dealing with them is they specialize in farm loans. You also pay fees for renewals and loan set up, just like the banks.

That is a lie? BULLSH$#! I don't like being called a liar. :mad: Do some research and tell me how Farm Credit is funded verses "any bank". :? Compare the tax structures of Farm Credit verses "any bank". :? :? Define for me a GSE. :? While you're learning, post for all of us the "huge profits" banks make. Compare that with Farm Credit's profits. :shock:

A lie is any untrue statement. You said any person with a Farm Credit loan is getting a subsidy. A subsidy would be lower interest than the market offers else where, or cash back, or loans cancelled, NONE OF WHICH IS DONE. So therefore your statement was untrue, or a lie. I didn't call you a liar, but if the shoe fits take the label on yourself.

The way Farm Credit is funded is by profit made on their loans. Yes they are a crown Corporation, but check out their financials, they make a profit. Check out the 5 major Canadian banks, they have made record profits each quarter as well, much higher than Farm Credit, but are still considered small by world bank standards. The biggest, The Royal, is something like 20th worldwide, but maybe lower.

Independant banks in the US would be more like Credit Unions than banks. Any privately owned one sure wouldn't be a blip on the screen in the world market.
 
Jason, "A lie is any untrue statement. You said any person with a Farm Credit loan is getting a subsidy. A subsidy would be lower interest than the market offers else where, or cash back, or loans cancelled, NONE OF WHICH IS DONE. So therefore your statement was untrue, or a lie. I didn't call you a liar, but if the shoe fits take the label on yourself."

Maybe we're talking about two different deals. I'm talking about Farm Credit in the US. They ARE getting lower interest rates - especially on long term RE. They ARE getting money back.

Jason, "Independant banks in the US would be more like Credit Unions than banks. Any privately owned one sure wouldn't be a blip on the screen in the world market."

Maybe that is the case up there, but certainly not down here. Independant banks and credit unions have a totally different tax structure. Banks are regulated by the FDIC, credit unions by the FCLA?
 
Big Muddy rancher said:
MRJ said:
Boys, relax! I heard Bush and Johanns as saying to other nations (Europe in particluar) which pay large subsidies, that the US will cut out subsidies WHEN or AFTER every nation does the same.

BMR, where in the USA have you known of anyone to be turned away from hospitals for needed medical care? I believe anyone can get medical care if they want/need it and the hospitals have to make up the loss on those of us who pay, and pay and PAY! Add to that our additional taxes for the government mandated medical programs!

MRJ


If the above is true why are so many Americans upset that we have scocialized medical care. Sounds like you have it for some in the US but don't treat everyone fairly. Why do so many Americans want to tear down Canad's system ? Is your system better? If we had to pay for all care would some Canadians not be going to the US and tying up your system more. I have seen it both ways as my kids were born in the US, and we have doctored some as it was the closest hospital.

BMR, I don't necessarily believe your system is better or worse than ours, and ours seems rapidly to be imitating yours as we move away from the individual or his employer providing insurance as part of benefits packaging. The Rapid City Journal carried an editorial on the high cost of health care. Here are some of the points.

These high costs are triggering worries of rationing of care with proble decisions on what care we can get being made by a government manual or a bureaucrat rather than the patient and his doctor.

Research has developed so many extraordinary medical and pharmaceutical treatments......at a cost......often extreme.....yet lives and quality of life are improved.......who will decide what is too much, or "worth it" even at extreme cost?

More than half of all Americans have the majority of their health costs paie by taxes: Medicare, Medicaid and health care plans (insurance) provided to government workers (military people, city employees, school teachers, Congressmen) as an employment benefit, or by hospitals or local governments as care for the uninsured.

The point of the editorial is that people do not take control of the costs of their health care, often do not even know the costs because the insurance or someone else is responsible for the costs and that is more was up to the individual, we would not put up with exhorbitant costs. Guess there must not be many of us paying our own insurance premiums, according to the story. I know that our insurance costs have been absolutely crippling, yet when I had cancer it really served us well, though am certain we have paid in far more than we ever used in health care costs. We have always wondered if we had been better off had we put the premium money into solid investments rather than insurance, but were afraid to not be covered.

Those who claim bankruptcy has been forced on people with health problems puzzle me. I know people who have had absolutely impossibly high medical bills. Some have told me that the billing agencies have told them to set a figure for monthly payments that they can live with and continue to make those payments and not to worry about the balance, that they will only be expected to make an honest effort at payment. And they did not lose their ranch or business.

My personal take is that if we could only end the fraud and cheating by outright con artists, it would go a long way to making health care affordable.

There is plenty wrong when we see people demanding abortion for any reason at any stage, and others paying dearly to save the life of a preemie baby they love dearly.

There is plenty wrong when we see people choosing their lifestyles and habits of gambling, booze, cigarettes, and drugs over purchasing insurance and health care for their children.

LIfe is filled with choices, and too often too many of us make wrong ones and expect others to pay the costs.

MRJ
 
If the Canadian system is so terrible, why is it that each time I visit my Dr. in a small clinic in a very small border town, over 1/2 the chairs in the waiting room are crowded with my Mt. neighbours?
They are quick to tell us how lucky they are to live near enough to the Canadian border to take advantage of the superior and cheaper medical care in Canada.
 
Border rancher said:
If the Canadian system is so terrible, why is it that each time I visit my Dr. in a small clinic in a very small border town, over 1/2 the chairs in the waiting room are crowded with my Mt. neighbours?
They are quick to tell us how lucky they are to live near enough to the Canadian border to take advantage of the superior and cheaper medical care in Canada.

I will agree with you Border Rancher-- I know 10-15 people from my area that have gone to Regina to have laser surgery on their eyes, so they no longer have to wear glasses...Price is about 1/10th the cost of what it costs in Billings.....
And what really surprised me with some I've talked to is the waiting period.... I expected they would wait for some time in Canada- but those I talked to said it was just the opposite- lot longer waiting period in the states....One said that he had his surgery 1 week after he called in Regina- but couldn't get an appointment in Billings for months.... :?
 
Last time i checked(a few yrs back now) interest at farm credit was higher than a regular bank. Some times farm credit will give you a loan when a regular bank wont.
 

Latest posts

Back
Top