Larrry
Well-known member
So You Think You Know Your Rights?
Julia Shaw
December 15, 2011 at 1:00 pm
(4)
It seems people think that they have a right to everything these days: a right to the Internet, to free health care, to a good job, and to a free college education. The Supreme Court is famous for finding new rights in the "penumbras" and "emanations" of the Constitution.
Today marks the 220th anniversary of the ratification of the Bill of Rights. What better opportunity to look at the rights the Constitution actually guarantees?
A right is not merely something you want or claim. You may, for example, want a better job, but that does not mean you have a right to that job. The framers understood a right to mean something that justly belongs to you, that others have a duty not to interfere with, and that creates a claim against anyone who would deprive you of it. The Declaration of Independence explains that people possess certain rights by nature and that governments exist to secure these rights.
What does this mean for the Constitution? By creating a document of limited, enumerated powers, the framers crafted a government that would allow individuals to enjoytheir rights. The Constitution outlines the structure of American government, by allocating powers to particular branches on specific subjects, but it rarely discusses rights. At various points, the Constitution prohibits ex post facto laws and bills of attainder at the state and national levels, requires criminal trials to have juries, and guarantees the writ of habeas corpus (except in cases of rebellion or invasion). Yet, the word "right" appears only once in the entire document: the Patents Clause, which empowers Congress "to promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries."
The first Congress amended the Constitution to include the first 10 amendments, collectively known as the Bill of Rights. James Madison drafted them not only to counter false interpretations of each branch's enumerated powers but also to support a public understanding of individual liberty that would assist citizens in the task of defending their liberties.
The First Amendment clarifies that the federal government may not interfere with particular substantive political rights involving religion, speech, press, assembly, and petition. Likewise, the Second Amendment guarantees an individual right to keep and bear arms. The next six amendments deal with more procedural political rights, mostly restraints on criminal procedure that were present in most of the state constitutions. For instance, the Fourth Amendment outlines the procedures for obtaining a warrant, and the Fifth Amendment prohibits the sovereign from trying a person twice for the same offense. The Ninth and Tenth Amendments summarize the Constitution's purpose—to secure individual liberty not by having a comprehensive list of rights but by allocating powers between state governments and the branches of the federal government.
The Bill of Rights, properly understood, serves as a check on the federal government's power. In Securing Liberty: The Purpose and Importance of the Bill of Rights, Joseph Postell argues that "implicit in the story surrounding our Bill of Rights is the proposition that the liberties of a nation can only be secured by citizens of firm conviction who understand our rights and liberties and will actively defend them." This makes understanding the nature of rights all the more important. If we continue to define "rights" to be anything we could possibly want and insist that government is obligated pay for them, then we will place ourselves in the position of constantly appealing to government to give us more "rights." In this subservient position, we cannot sufficiently guard our liberty from government encroachment.
As you celebrate Bill of Rights Day today, take time to read the Constitution and the first 10 amendments. Challenge yourself to study your natural rights for the sake of knowing your liberties and defending them
Julia Shaw
December 15, 2011 at 1:00 pm
(4)
It seems people think that they have a right to everything these days: a right to the Internet, to free health care, to a good job, and to a free college education. The Supreme Court is famous for finding new rights in the "penumbras" and "emanations" of the Constitution.
Today marks the 220th anniversary of the ratification of the Bill of Rights. What better opportunity to look at the rights the Constitution actually guarantees?
A right is not merely something you want or claim. You may, for example, want a better job, but that does not mean you have a right to that job. The framers understood a right to mean something that justly belongs to you, that others have a duty not to interfere with, and that creates a claim against anyone who would deprive you of it. The Declaration of Independence explains that people possess certain rights by nature and that governments exist to secure these rights.
What does this mean for the Constitution? By creating a document of limited, enumerated powers, the framers crafted a government that would allow individuals to enjoytheir rights. The Constitution outlines the structure of American government, by allocating powers to particular branches on specific subjects, but it rarely discusses rights. At various points, the Constitution prohibits ex post facto laws and bills of attainder at the state and national levels, requires criminal trials to have juries, and guarantees the writ of habeas corpus (except in cases of rebellion or invasion). Yet, the word "right" appears only once in the entire document: the Patents Clause, which empowers Congress "to promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries."
The first Congress amended the Constitution to include the first 10 amendments, collectively known as the Bill of Rights. James Madison drafted them not only to counter false interpretations of each branch's enumerated powers but also to support a public understanding of individual liberty that would assist citizens in the task of defending their liberties.
The First Amendment clarifies that the federal government may not interfere with particular substantive political rights involving religion, speech, press, assembly, and petition. Likewise, the Second Amendment guarantees an individual right to keep and bear arms. The next six amendments deal with more procedural political rights, mostly restraints on criminal procedure that were present in most of the state constitutions. For instance, the Fourth Amendment outlines the procedures for obtaining a warrant, and the Fifth Amendment prohibits the sovereign from trying a person twice for the same offense. The Ninth and Tenth Amendments summarize the Constitution's purpose—to secure individual liberty not by having a comprehensive list of rights but by allocating powers between state governments and the branches of the federal government.
The Bill of Rights, properly understood, serves as a check on the federal government's power. In Securing Liberty: The Purpose and Importance of the Bill of Rights, Joseph Postell argues that "implicit in the story surrounding our Bill of Rights is the proposition that the liberties of a nation can only be secured by citizens of firm conviction who understand our rights and liberties and will actively defend them." This makes understanding the nature of rights all the more important. If we continue to define "rights" to be anything we could possibly want and insist that government is obligated pay for them, then we will place ourselves in the position of constantly appealing to government to give us more "rights." In this subservient position, we cannot sufficiently guard our liberty from government encroachment.
As you celebrate Bill of Rights Day today, take time to read the Constitution and the first 10 amendments. Challenge yourself to study your natural rights for the sake of knowing your liberties and defending them
