• If you are having problems logging in please use the Contact Us in the lower right hand corner of the forum page for assistance.

Tax Cut For Hugo Chavez

Mike

Well-known member
Tax Cut For Hugo?
INVESTOR'S BUSINESS DAILY

Posted 2/29/2008

Energy: If there's anything more dumbfounding than the House's imposition of higher taxes on oil companies, thereby guaranteeing higher prices at the pump, it's the exemption voted for Venezuela's state oil firm.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Related Topics: Budget & Tax Policy | Energy


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------


It goes to show that Congress is more willing to empower dictators than to get serious about America's energy supply.

On the surface, H.R. 5321 is awful all by itself. Passing 236-182 last week, the bill scrapped the tax deduction routinely given to the major integrated oil companies — Exxon, Chevron, BP, Shell and ConocoPhillips — that helps them explore, extract, refine and market the energy that drives our economy.

This will make it $18 billion more costly for those companies to produce oil. To the House this is a good thing, because large oil companies with large market capitalizations already earn too much.

"The big five oil companies recently reported record profits for 2007, with Exxon Mobil earning $40.6 billion last year alone — the largest corporate profit in American history," Speaker Nancy Pelosi said Friday. "While oil company profits have quadrupled, high energy prices continue to squeeze American families."

Don't worry, the $18 billion will still be spent. It'll just be turned into pork for so-called alternatives and renewables that thus far have failed to produce energy in a free market.

Congress made this even worse by ensuring that its discrimination against the big oils would benefit Citgo, which happens to be owned by those same companies' worst tormentor abroad — the brutal leftist dictatorship of Venezuela's Hugo Chavez.

Under this bill, the dictator's oil subsidiary keeps its 6% deduction for U.S. domestic manufacturing — the one the American oil companies lose — because Citgo, technically, buys from Chavez.

How's that for logic? Worse, the bill includes distorted incentives that will do exactly the opposite of what Congress intends.

• By taxing big oil companies, Congress gives them less cash to develop new sources of supply that would bring these prices down. America's large integrated oil companies are profitable, but they also are the biggest spenders on exploration and R&D technologies. They have the greatest capacity to reach into the earth's remotest regions to produce energy; now, they'll do less of that.

• The bill will force these five companies to pass $18 billion in costs on to buyers. Energy companies, like all private enterprises, don't eat new taxes — their consumers do. We'll pay at the pump.

• Meanwhile, U.S. oil companies will have a long-term incentive to locate operations abroad, if only to match the advantage enjoyed by companies such as Citgo. When that happens, America will be more dependent than ever on the whims of foreign petro-tyrants like Chavez.

"The Democrats' blustery rhetoric on energy couldn't be more wrongheaded or insulting," one angry GOP House aide told IBD. "Raising taxes on producers of American energy here at home will only send good-paying jobs overseas, further increase our dependence on foreign oil and make gasoline even more expensive."

Last year, by the way, Venezuela confiscated assets worth about $6 billion from all five of these same American companies.

Congress seems unmoved by the attack on U.S. companies' sovereignty. Exxon executives recently charged that Congress' rabid rhetoric against American oil producers had undermined their efforts to reason with Caracas.

With this bill, Congress only shows its unwillingness to face up to reality. While it passed the House, there's still hope that it will die in the Senate. If not, President Bush vows a veto.

Such boneheaded legislation, however, should never have been introduced. At a time when we're trying to stave off recession and bring down the record-high price of crude, Congress is only making matters worse by casting U.S. companies as the enemy.

Click here for copyright permissions!
Copyright 2000-2008 Investor's Business Daily, Inc.
 

Latest posts

Top