• If you are having problems logging in please use the Contact Us in the lower right hand corner of the forum page for assistance.

The Effect of Country of Origin Labeling

Help Support Ranchers.net:

ocm

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 16, 2005
Messages
779
Reaction score
0
Wal-Mart to sell only U.S. shrimp in 3 states
The Biloxi Sun Herald, MS
August 25, 2006
By MIKE KELLER

Wal-Mart seafood counters in Alabama, Florida, and Texas will carry only wild shrimp caught in American waters, thanks to overwhelming demand by consumers, a shrimp-industry group said Thursday.

Almost 300 stores in the three states will carry only shrimp caught in the Gulf and South Atlantic through distributor Penguin Frozen Foods, one of the nation's largest suppliers of domestic shrimp.

"Wal-Mart's decision to exclusively feature domestic wild-caught shrimp at seafood counters in three states will help sustain an important industry and traditional way of life in our country," said Mark Watters, the director of retail operations at Penguin.

The company's move to back American shrimpers could put a dent in a shrimp market dominated by Southeast Asian imports.

According to Wild American Shrimp, an industry group, about 85 percent of shrimp eaten in America comes from another country, with Thailand, China, Vietnam and Bangladesh leading the suppliers.

Wal-Mart decided to sell American shrimp exclusively after a November 2005 agreement to offer both American and foreign shrimp in 900 stores.

"The response was so overwhelming from consumers that these three states will sell the U.S. product exclusively," said Jenny Schmitt, a spokeswoman for Wild American Shrimp. "The cost is lower on foreign shrimp but it's a different product. We certify American shrimp for size, quality and flavor."

Richard Gollott, an owner of shrimp processor Golden Gulf Coast Packing, a competitor of Penguin Frozen Foods, thinks Wal-Mart's decision was good for consumers and shrimpers.

"Any time we can move into more markets we didn't have previously, it creates more demand for our product and prices move up," Gollott said. "We need to help the fishermen from going out of business. We would like to have more Americans eat domestic shrimp."

LOAD-DATE: August 25, 2006
 
Consumer driven, voluntary labeling with real value.

That is the type of 'labeling' NCBA supports!

Wonder how long it will be before activist groups decry the 'decimation' of the 'wildlife'?????

MRJ
 
MRJ said:
Consumer driven, voluntary labeling with real value.

That is the type of 'labeling' NCBA supports!

Wonder how long it will be before activist groups decry the 'decimation' of the 'wildlife'?????

MRJ


:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

I'm glad you approve of what is going on, but COOL on shrimp is not voluntary - not what NCBA supports!

Walmart using US shrimp is the only consumer driven part of this story. There was an article a few weeks ago about Korean retailers getting rung up for intentionally mislabeling imported lamb as domestic. There's something to be learned by you anti-COOL folks here if you open your eyes.
 
MRJ said:
Consumer driven, voluntary labeling with real value.

That is the type of 'labeling' NCBA supports!

Wonder how long it will be before activist groups decry the 'decimation' of the 'wildlife'?????

MRJ

Too bad the consumer will never get the chance to choose if NCBA has their way. :roll:
 
Say MRJ, the ScoringAg Labeled product , Its SSI-EID Traceback code is driven,by the consumer and its voluntary labeling with real value for the producer .
 
MRJ said:
Consumer driven, voluntary labeling with real value.

That is the type of 'labeling' NCBA supports!

Wonder how long it will be before activist groups decry the 'decimation' of the 'wildlife'?????

MRJ

This must be another one of those subjects that Maxine "hasn't had time to keep informed on" and doesn't reallize that the MANDATORY-COOL law on shrimp and fish was allowed to go into effect, when it was killed on all other meat- and has been working very well, with many positive results for the respective industries :roll:

I guess NCBA forgot to tell her about that :wink: :lol:
 
Oldtimer said:
MRJ said:
Consumer driven, voluntary labeling with real value.

That is the type of 'labeling' NCBA supports!

Wonder how long it will be before activist groups decry the 'decimation' of the 'wildlife'?????

MRJ

This must be another one of those subjects that Maxine "hasn't had time to keep informed on" and doesn't reallize that the MANDATORY-COOL law on shrimp and fish was allowed to go into effect, when it was killed on all other meat- and has been working very well, with many positive results for the respective industries :roll:

I guess NCBA forgot to tell her about that :wink: :lol:

But, but, but, but, but, OT. The fish and shrimp deal is because of the inferior fish and shrimp that was being dumped in the U.S. as being USA raised seafood. Don't you see? :wink:
 
mike: The fish and shrimp deal is because of the inferior fish and shrimp that was being dumped in the U.S. as being USA raised seafood.


how much of the 'inferior' product is being brought in labelled as usa product and how much is being bought up by american interests and then re-labelled once onshore? americans always see the rest of the world as the bad guys but in many, if not most, cases it is american interests who misrepresent for their own gain.
 
don said:
mike: The fish and shrimp deal is because of the inferior fish and shrimp that was being dumped in the U.S. as being USA raised seafood.


how much of the 'inferior' product is being brought in labelled as usa product and how much is being bought up by american interests and then re-labelled once onshore? americans always see the rest of the world as the bad guys but in many, if not most, cases it is american interests who misrepresent for their own gain.

The Vietnamese "Catfish" (not really) almost singlehandedly ruined the US farm raised catfish business. Those wild river fish that ate the sewage in those rivers was passed off as USA catfish by someone.

I know not who, but it doesn't matter. Shouldn't have been done by anyone. But I suspect some multinational Corp had a hand in it.
 
As don says those companies importing and selling it for profit are in most cases AMERICAN owned by AMERICANS. It sure seems easy for some to always blame the exporter when all they are doing is supplying the product.
 
Bill said:
As don says those companies importing and selling it for profit are in most cases AMERICAN owned by AMERICANS. It sure seems easy for some to always blame the exporter when all they are doing is supplying the product.

And most of the people in AMERICAN jails are AMERICANS, too. It sure is easy to blame those drug dealers when all they were doing was supplying a product.
 
Sandhusker said:
Bill said:
As don says those companies importing and selling it for profit are in most cases AMERICAN owned by AMERICANS. It sure seems easy for some to always blame the exporter when all they are doing is supplying the product.

And most of the people in AMERICAN jails are AMERICANS, too. It sure is easy to blame those drug dealers when all they were doing was supplying a product.
You're sure reaching with that one (as the blamers usually do). :roll: :roll: Yes and that product is illegal. Comparing COOL to the drug trade? Give us a break.

So is Wal-Mart now one the good guys? No talk of the cheap imported Chinese junk in this thread? No talk of them strong armiing on pricing such as someone said earlier with Vlasic?

Talk about building strawmen! :lol: :lol: :lol:
 
sandhusker: And most of the people in AMERICAN jails are AMERICANS, too.

there's your solution. make it a crime to buy canadian cattle!!!!!
you can force americans to buy american cattle and if only you had some influence in congress you wouldn't need mcool; you could make it a felony for consumers to buy canadian beef. get your lawyers on it. ol' shae can put out a press release.
 
Bill said:
Sandhusker said:
Bill said:
As don says those companies importing and selling it for profit are in most cases AMERICAN owned by AMERICANS. It sure seems easy for some to always blame the exporter when all they are doing is supplying the product.

And most of the people in AMERICAN jails are AMERICANS, too. It sure is easy to blame those drug dealers when all they were doing was supplying a product.
You're sure reaching with that one (as the blamers usually do). :roll: :roll: Yes and that product is illegal. Comparing COOL to the drug trade? Give us a break.

So is Wal-Mart now one the good guys? No talk of the cheap imported Chinese junk in this thread? No talk of them strong armiing on pricing such as someone said earlier with Vlasic?

Talk about building strawmen! :lol: :lol: :lol:

Mike posted; Those wild river fish that ate the sewage in those rivers was passed off as USA catfish by someone. "

I consider that as an equal to selling drugs.
 
Mike posted; Those wild river fish that ate the sewage in those rivers was passed off as USA catfish by someone. "

Some would consider those "Natural", unlike the farm raised!
 
Murgen said:
Mike posted; Those wild river fish that ate the sewage in those rivers was passed off as USA catfish by someone. "

Some would consider those "Natural", unlike the farm raised!

There's not much "natural" anywhere anymore. Humans have polluted about everything we have come in contact with. It's a sin that so many or our "natural" lakes and streams are so pulluted any fish out of them comes with a warning.
 
The point of this thread sure got diverted quickly!!!!

"The response was so overwhelming from consumers that these three states will sell the U.S. product exclusively," said Jenny Schmitt, a spokeswoman for Wild American Shrimp. "The cost is lower on foreign shrimp but it's a different product. We certify American shrimp for size, quality and flavor."

MCOOL for fish and seafood is working without all the dire consequences that were predicted...AND the consumers responded!!!!!! :D I don't understand you Canadians...if your beef is as good as you claim, you should be demanding MCOOL!!!!!!!!!! :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:
 
Maxine must not have been able to get ahold of any NCBAers in the know yet, to explain to her how come they forgot to tell her about the M-COOL law thats in effect on shrimp and fish :wink: :lol: :lol:

Funny how something NCBA/USDA claimed is so unworkable- is working so well in those industries- even enough consumer demand to have Walmart carry only US product :D .....
 

Latest posts

Top