• If you are having problems logging in please use the Contact Us in the lower right hand corner of the forum page for assistance.

U.S. ranchers' group seeks early judgment in devastating mad

Help Support Ranchers.net:

Manitoba_Rancher

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 10, 2005
Messages
2,117
Reaction score
0
Location
Canada
U.S. ranchers' group seeks early judgment in devastating mad cow case
BETH GORHAM



WASHINGTON (CP) - A U.S. ranchers' group blocking the border to Canadian cattle is asking for an early judgment in the mad cow case, even before a court hearing scheduled for July in Montana.

R-CALF United Stockgrowers of America submitted the request this week to the U.S. District Court judge that sided with the group in March and slapped a temporary ban on the cattle trade just days before it was supposed to resume March 7.

U.S. observers were unsure of the likelihood that Judge Richard Cebull would make a move to decide the long-term fate of the border before the full hearing scheduled for July 27 in Billings, Mont.

"Very rarely does that happen," said a government spokesman who didn't want to be named.

But some experts said there's a chance of an early ruling in the case, which has devastated the Canadian industry and U.S. meat packers who said they're losing an estimated $38 million US a week without enough cows to process.

The U.S. Department of Agriculture has until June 8 to respond to the latest legal salvo from R-CALF, which also wants an end to trade in processed-beef products.

"We'll lay out why the court should not move quickly," said U.S. Justice Department spokesman Charles Miller.

"The court will wait for us to file our response."

Dozens of U.S. cattle and farm groups representing the majority of ranchers are supporting Canada in the legal battle.

But R-CALF has long argued Canadian beef and cattle pose safety risks because there have been three mad cow cases north of the border.

It argues officials failed to properly assess the risk of Canadian imports to U.S. herds and humans and acted too quickly to reopen the border.

The group also criticizes testing levels for mad cow, or bovine spongiform encephalopathy, on both sides of the border, saying they're too low.

The Agribusiness Freedom Foundation released a rebuttal this week of R-CALF's claims Canada doesn't test enough cattle, saying tests each month of 2004 and 2005 have exceeded what the World Organization for Animal Health recommends for an entire year.

Canada has about seven million cattle over the age of 30 months, thought to be at higher risk than younger cows for contracting BSE.

It completed 23,550 tests in 2004 and have already tested 22,883 so far this year, the Canadian Food Inspection Agency said.

"R-CALF has grossly misrepresented the situation to the public and in court," said Steve Dittmer, the U.S. foundation's executive vice-president.

"How R-CALF reaches it conclusions and justifies its allegations somehow seems to have nothing to do with the real numbers."

The U.S. beef ban began in May 2003 after Canada's first mad cow case, costing the industry some $7 billion Cdn.

The Kansas Department of Agriculture estimates the U.S. beef industry, hit by its own mad cow case 18 months ago and struggling without Canadian imports, lost up to $4.7 billion US last year.

U.S. officials launched an appeal of the March ruling in Montana granting a temporary extension of the cattle ban. But no date has yet been set in the U.S. Court of Appeals.



© The Canadian Press, 2005


This is bad news for the Canadian beef Industry. :cry:
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Several of the coffee shop guys have a joke that they are waiting until calves get to be $1.50 at 650 before they sell...But if the Judge issues an early judgement and closes the border to all boxed beef, it might not be a joke anymore- it might be true :) ........
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Big Muddy rancher said:
Oldtimer has a federal judge ever been replaced because of a misuse of power.

If they are found guilty of committing a crime or proven incompetent because of mental disease are about the only ways-- That won't happen with this one.....
 

agman

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 10, 2005
Messages
1,664
Reaction score
0
Location
Denver, CO
Oldtimer said:
Big Muddy rancher said:
Oldtimer has a federal judge ever been replaced because of a misuse of power.

If they are found guilty of committing a crime or proven incompetent because of mental disease are about the only ways-- That won't happen with this one.....

Evidently you think more highly of him then is the view by many in the Ninth Circuit District.
 

Sandhusker

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 10, 2005
Messages
18,486
Reaction score
0
Location
Nebraska
agman said:
Oldtimer said:
Big Muddy rancher said:
Oldtimer has a federal judge ever been replaced because of a misuse of power.

If they are found guilty of committing a crime or proven incompetent because of mental disease are about the only ways-- That won't happen with this one.....

Evidently you think more highly of him then is the view by many in the Ninth Circuit District.

Isn't the Ninth Circuit Court the same bunch who ruled the words "Under God" in the Pledge of Allegiance were unconstitutional? They're sure thought of highly in ranching country.
 

Kato

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 10, 2005
Messages
2,679
Reaction score
0
Location
Manitoba - At the end of the road
How highly Judge Cebull is regarded in Canada doesn't affect his judgements.

I don't suppose these judges care about how they are regarded in Montana either. :wink:

The big question is "Why the hurry now? So far it's been a policy of delay delay delay, by whatever method is handy. What has changed?"
 

CattleCo

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 11, 2005
Messages
543
Reaction score
0
"Several of the coffee shop guys have a joke that they are waiting until calves get to be $1.50 at 650 before they sell...But if the Judge issues an early judgement and closes the border to all boxed beef, it might not be a joke anymore- it might be true ........"

I doubt anybody is going to close the Canadian border to boxed beef! Oldtimer, your memory is fading......remember 15 dollar soybeans, 5 dollar Corn, AND 10 CENT HOGS???? If you think we cannot have 60 dollar fats again you are really smoking some real good grass hay!!! I think we have pushed the consumer of Beef in this country to the limit on price. I cannot believe the so called "smart people" in this industry that think we will have the "good times" forever! We have had a great run and I think we have a little gas left in the tank, but the tank will run dry someday. Then we start over and have the opportunitites to look like idiots again!!
 
A

Anonymous

Guest
Cattle Co.: "We have had a great run and I think we have a little gas left in the tank, but the tank will run dry someday."

At that point the "AND HOW MUCH YA GONNA GIVE FOR 'EM" market analysts will be back on the radio blaming packer concentration, captive supplies, imports, USDA, NCBA and any other scapegoat they can find for decreasing consumer demand while they spend those commission dollars on packer parasite lawsuits rather than increasing consumer demand.

Salebarn blamers are the downfall of this industry.


~SH~
 

Latest posts

Top