• If you are having problems logging in please use the Contact Us in the lower right hand corner of the forum page for assistance.

Ranchers.net

Welfare Pays Better Than Work, Study Finds
$36,000 a Year in Hawaii

Welfare benefits are far more generous than commonly thought and

substantially exceed the amount a recipient could earn in an entry-level

job. As a result, recipients are likely to choose welfare over work,

increasing long-term dependence. Those are the principal findings in "The

Work vs. Welfare Trade-Off" (Policy Analysis no. 240) by Michael Tanner,

director of health and welfare studies; Stephen Moore, director of fiscal

policy studies; and David Hartman, CEO of Hartland Bank in Austin, Texas.

The paper was released at the height of the welfare debate in Congress.



The study examines the combined value of benefits--including Aid to

Families with Dependent Children, food stamps, Medicaid, and others--for

a typical welfare recipient in each of the 50 states. The value of those

tax-free benefits is then compared with the amount of take-home income a

worker would have left after paying taxes on an equivalent pretax income.

The following are among the study's findings.



* To match the value of welfare benefits, a mother with two children would

have to earn as much as $36,400 in Hawaii or as little as $11,500 in

Mississippi.


* In New York, Massachusetts, Connecticut, the District of Columbia,

Hawaii, Alaska, and Rhode Island, welfare pays more than a $12.00-an-hour

job--or more than two and a half times the minimum wage.


* In 40 states welfare pays more than an $8.00-an-hour job. In 17 states

the welfare package is more generous than a $10.00-an-hour job.


* Welfare benefits are especially generous in large cities. Welfare

provides the equivalent of an hourly pretax wage of $14.75 in New York

City, $12.45 in Philadelphia, $11.35 in Baltimore, and $10.90 in Detroit.


* In 9 states welfare pays more than the average first-year salary for a

teacher. In 29 states it pays more than the average starting salary for a

secretary. In 47 states welfare pays more than a janitor earns. Indeed, in

the 6 most generous states, benefits exceed the entry-level salary for a

computer programmer.



The authors conclude that if Congress or state governments are serious

about reducing welfare dependence and rewarding work, the most promising

reform is to cut benefit levels substantially.



The study has been the subject of major news coverage. In a September 28

Wall Street Journal guest column, Tanner and Moore wrote, "The welfare

reform proposals just passed by the Senate, and the earlier House version,

are designed to reduce 'hard-core' welfare dependency and reward work. But

we believe the most critical public policy implication of our findings is

that ultimately these goals can be accomplished only by cutting benefit

levels substantially. Unless and until this is done, Congress will have

failed to end welfare as we know it."



Hourly Wage Equivalent of Welfare


Hawaii $17.50 Alaska 15.48 Massachusetts 14.66 Connecticut 14.23 Washington, D.C. 13.99 New York 13.13 New Jersey 12.74 Rhode Island 12.55 California 11.59 Virginia 11.11 Maryland 10.96 New Hampshire 10.96 Maine 10.38 Delaware 10.34 Colorado 10.05 Vermont 10.05 Minnesota 10.00 Washington 9.95 Nevada 9.71 Utah 9.57 Michigan 9.47 Pennsylvania 9.47 Illinois 9.33 Wisconsin 9.33 Oregon 9.23 Wyoming 9.18 Indiana 9.13 Iowa 9.13 New Mexico 8.94 Florida 8.75 Idaho 8.65 Oklahoma 8.51 Kansas 8.46 North Dakota 8.46 Georgia 8.37 Ohio 8.37 South Dakata 8.32 Louisana 8.17 Kentucky 8.08 North Carolina 8.08 Montana 7.84 South Carolina 7.79 Nebraska 7.64 Texas 7.31 West Virginia 7.31 Missouri 7.16 Arizona 6.78 Tennessee 6.59 Arkansas 6.35 Alabama 6.25 Mississippi 5.53


[ Table of Contents (Policy Repor
Top