• If you are having problems logging in please use the Contact Us in the lower right hand corner of the forum page for assistance.

Reply to thread

True but we also need to do our sums correctly and calculate what the premium really is.  I read a few years back a comment by a bull producer (of multiple breeds) in his sale catalog that "for the first time in his life black angus calves were selling for more $cwt than tan charolais calves" This observation was obviously an earth shattering revelation to him because he was selling more Charolais than Angus at that time. I got to thinking afterwards that the statement he made really wasn't all that remarkable.

If you sell 500lb Angus calves at $105/cwt versus Charolais at $100/cwt sure that's $25 advantage to the Angus. However if your Charolais bull is worth his salt his calves will weigh 80lbs more than the straight Angus at the same age, advantage $55 to the Charolais. So much for the Angus outselling the Charolais. I have never seen good black steers outsell good tan char. steers in western Canada by more than 5c/lb.

I don't have a dog in this race as I don't breed either but I think no matter your breed or breed preference you need to be careful not to buy into the BS and fashion influenced trends of the day.


What city in Missouri has a big arch?
Back
Top