William Kanitz
Well-known member
Scientists investigating whether C. diff can be caught by eating meat
19:00:25 EDT Oct 3, 2006
Canadian Press: HELEN BRANSWELL
TORONTO (CP) - Scientists in Canada and the United States are exploring the unsettling question of whether C. difficile can be contracted by eating meat after finding evidence of infection in food animals, including dairy calves in Ontario.
A new study by researchers at the Ontario Veterinary College in Guelph supports the idea, even revealing that the bacterium has already been isolated from meat in the retail food system.
The study further shows that a strain of Clostridium difficile that has caused severe hospital outbreaks in Quebec, Britain and parts of the U.S. has been found it the feces of dairy calves in Ontario. Earlier U.S. studies have found other strains of C. difficile in piglets.
Scientists admit they don't know whether people can become infected and develop C. difficile-associated disease through eating meat containing the bacterium. But it's important to find out, they say.
The senior author of the Guelph study suggests the issue boils down to two key questions.
"If it's in the animal can it make it into retail meat? And if it's in retail meat, can it cause disease?" Dr. Scott Weese, a veterinarian who specializes in diseases that pass between animals and humans, said in an interview Tuesday.
Weese and his co-authors admit - in rather vague terms - that they think they know the answer to the first question.
"Although C. difficile is not considered a foodborne pathogen, it has been identified in . . . retail meat from grocery stores in Ontario," they wrote in their article, to be published in an upcoming issue of the journal Emerging Infectious Diseases.
The study notes that finding has not yet been published in the scientific literature. And Weese would not go into detail, saying a scientific article detailing that work is in the publication pipeline.
But he cautioned that it's too soon to conclude that the presence of the bacterium in meat automatically means people can contract C. difficile-associated diarrhea by chowing down on a burger or a pork chop.
"What does ingesting a few C. diff spores mean to a person? That's completely unclear," Weese said.
Scientists and officials in the field of public health would dearly love to find out, however. Several key U.S. agencies - the Food and Drug Administration, the Food Safety and Inspection Service and the National Institutes of Health - are actively following the research, some of which is being done at the Centers for Disease Control in Atlanta.
That agency's lead expert on C. difficile is cautious about drawing a link between food and the disease at this point.
"It's something we're actively looking at. Too soon to say," said Dr. Clifford McDonald.
But the University of Arizona scientist who found the bacterium in pigs said it's hard to believe food isn't a potential source for some people.
"It is being looked at, that's for sure," said Glenn Songer, a veterinary microbiologist. "Looking at it from where we are now, I can't see any reason why that wouldn't be the case."
C. difficile has been traditionally thought of as an infection acquired in hospitals, where antibiotic use is rife. Antibiotics are known to upset the bacterial balance of the human gut, which can allow C. difficile to take root and flourish.
But increasingly researchers are discovering cases of C. difficile disease in people how haven't been hospitalized, begging the question: How did they contract the bacterium? Suspicion has been turning to the food supply.
The article by Weese and his colleagues reported on their effort to see if they could find C. difficile in calves in Ontario. They tested feces samples from 278 calves from 102 farms in the spring and summer of 2004, finding C. difficile spores in 31 calves (11 per cent).
Eight different strains of C. difficile were isolated, including the one blamed for hundreds of deaths in Quebec, Britain and parts of the U.S. The authors said the cattle strains were "indistinguishable" from those that have infected humans.
Weese said several different possibilities could be at play.
"It could be that these strains have evolved in parallel in different species. It could be that there was a single event where they moved from one species to another and it's not an ongoing problem. Or it could be that there is regular movement of various types of C. difficile between different species in all directions.
"And we need to figure out which one of those is most likely - and the clinical relevance of that too."
A number of scientists studying the question acknowledge that they may just now be seeing something that has existed all along, something no one bothered to look for until severe hospital outbreaks revved up interest in the bug.
Jon Brazier, a microbiologist with the National Public Health Service of Wales, suspects that may be the case. Brazier and some colleagues looked for C. difficile in the environment about a decade ago. "We found it in rivers, lakes, even in sea water. Swimming pools," he said from Cardiff.
"My feeling is we all occasionally ingest C. diff spores of various types from time to time. And they don't do us any harm unless we happen to have our gut flora disturbed by antibiotics or indeed some other risk factors."
19:00:25 EDT Oct 3, 2006
Canadian Press: HELEN BRANSWELL
TORONTO (CP) - Scientists in Canada and the United States are exploring the unsettling question of whether C. difficile can be contracted by eating meat after finding evidence of infection in food animals, including dairy calves in Ontario.
A new study by researchers at the Ontario Veterinary College in Guelph supports the idea, even revealing that the bacterium has already been isolated from meat in the retail food system.
The study further shows that a strain of Clostridium difficile that has caused severe hospital outbreaks in Quebec, Britain and parts of the U.S. has been found it the feces of dairy calves in Ontario. Earlier U.S. studies have found other strains of C. difficile in piglets.
Scientists admit they don't know whether people can become infected and develop C. difficile-associated disease through eating meat containing the bacterium. But it's important to find out, they say.
The senior author of the Guelph study suggests the issue boils down to two key questions.
"If it's in the animal can it make it into retail meat? And if it's in retail meat, can it cause disease?" Dr. Scott Weese, a veterinarian who specializes in diseases that pass between animals and humans, said in an interview Tuesday.
Weese and his co-authors admit - in rather vague terms - that they think they know the answer to the first question.
"Although C. difficile is not considered a foodborne pathogen, it has been identified in . . . retail meat from grocery stores in Ontario," they wrote in their article, to be published in an upcoming issue of the journal Emerging Infectious Diseases.
The study notes that finding has not yet been published in the scientific literature. And Weese would not go into detail, saying a scientific article detailing that work is in the publication pipeline.
But he cautioned that it's too soon to conclude that the presence of the bacterium in meat automatically means people can contract C. difficile-associated diarrhea by chowing down on a burger or a pork chop.
"What does ingesting a few C. diff spores mean to a person? That's completely unclear," Weese said.
Scientists and officials in the field of public health would dearly love to find out, however. Several key U.S. agencies - the Food and Drug Administration, the Food Safety and Inspection Service and the National Institutes of Health - are actively following the research, some of which is being done at the Centers for Disease Control in Atlanta.
That agency's lead expert on C. difficile is cautious about drawing a link between food and the disease at this point.
"It's something we're actively looking at. Too soon to say," said Dr. Clifford McDonald.
But the University of Arizona scientist who found the bacterium in pigs said it's hard to believe food isn't a potential source for some people.
"It is being looked at, that's for sure," said Glenn Songer, a veterinary microbiologist. "Looking at it from where we are now, I can't see any reason why that wouldn't be the case."
C. difficile has been traditionally thought of as an infection acquired in hospitals, where antibiotic use is rife. Antibiotics are known to upset the bacterial balance of the human gut, which can allow C. difficile to take root and flourish.
But increasingly researchers are discovering cases of C. difficile disease in people how haven't been hospitalized, begging the question: How did they contract the bacterium? Suspicion has been turning to the food supply.
The article by Weese and his colleagues reported on their effort to see if they could find C. difficile in calves in Ontario. They tested feces samples from 278 calves from 102 farms in the spring and summer of 2004, finding C. difficile spores in 31 calves (11 per cent).
Eight different strains of C. difficile were isolated, including the one blamed for hundreds of deaths in Quebec, Britain and parts of the U.S. The authors said the cattle strains were "indistinguishable" from those that have infected humans.
Weese said several different possibilities could be at play.
"It could be that these strains have evolved in parallel in different species. It could be that there was a single event where they moved from one species to another and it's not an ongoing problem. Or it could be that there is regular movement of various types of C. difficile between different species in all directions.
"And we need to figure out which one of those is most likely - and the clinical relevance of that too."
A number of scientists studying the question acknowledge that they may just now be seeing something that has existed all along, something no one bothered to look for until severe hospital outbreaks revved up interest in the bug.
Jon Brazier, a microbiologist with the National Public Health Service of Wales, suspects that may be the case. Brazier and some colleagues looked for C. difficile in the environment about a decade ago. "We found it in rivers, lakes, even in sea water. Swimming pools," he said from Cardiff.
"My feeling is we all occasionally ingest C. diff spores of various types from time to time. And they don't do us any harm unless we happen to have our gut flora disturbed by antibiotics or indeed some other risk factors."