A bigger proportion of homes in New England and Maine use oil for heat than in any other region of the country because of its older housing stock and the late arrival of access to natural gas to many parts of the region, according to Jonathan Cogan of the Energy Information Administration in Washington. The portion of homes using oil ranges from 70 percent in Maine to 39 percent in Massachusetts.
Many residents avoided the sting of high oil prices during last winter's bitter cold by buying contracts that locked in prices early.
This summer, with prices already high, many people paid around $2 a gallon for contracts for this winter. Then Katrina hit the Gulf Coast, knocking out oil supplies and refineries and sending gasoline prices surging.
Heating oil prices spiked, as well, even though there's a greater supply of heating oil than in the past six or seven years, Nagusky said.
"It was a good thing for the oil companies. They relish this. It is an excuse, an excuse, to up it," said Smith, a widower who used to own a small grocery store, Smitty's, in Auburn. "There's no stopping it, and it's a shame."
Smith didn't buy his oil ahead, partly because he finds lock-in programs confusing.
He paid $1.89 per gallon to top off his 275-gallon tank this summer. Since then, the average price has climbed to about $2.50 a gallon in Maine.
New Hampshire's average price was $2.67, a jump of 23 percent in a month and 65 percent in a year, said Joe Broyles of the state Office of Energy and Planning.
Broyles won't hazard a guess about what oil will cost in the months ahead.
"There is nobody on the planet, or in the galaxy, who has a crystal ball big enough for that," he said.
Jamie Py of the Maine Oil Dealers Association said people shouldn't confuse local oil dealers, who buy from big suppliers, with industry giants that have enjoyed record profits. Like homeowners, local dealers are paying drastically more for their oil, he said.
The last resort for people who cannot pay to keep warm is federal heating assistance. Last year, 47,000 Maine households received $24 million in payments, said Dan Simpson of the Maine State Housing Authority. But the average benefit was $480 - not enough to fill a tank at today's prices.
How much heating aid there will be this winter remains uncertain.
There are not a lot options. Firewood prices have shot up to roughly $200 a cord in Maine, about $75 more than last year. Natural gas prices are up, too.
In Haverill, Mass., Rocco Pelosi, 78, has piled up firewood in his 1.5-acre backyard. That will help some, along with federal assistance. Without it, he's not sure what he and his wife would do.
"I don't want to cry on anybody's shoulder," he said. "I try to make ends meet. If I didn't have them to help me, I don't know what the hell I'd do."
Smith's backup plan also involves firewood. He has an extra bed set up next to his fireplace, and he'll sleep in it if he has to.