• If you are having problems logging in please use the Contact Us in the lower right hand corner of the forum page for assistance.

Is USDA Carrying Trade Too Far?

Help Support Ranchers.net:



USDA backs China poultry for US

USDA supports accepting Chinese poultry

It's an odd idea, says a consumer advocate, considering China's bird flu problems.



November 30, 2005

Washington, D.C. — Chinese chicken, anyone? It might not sound appealing to many diners, given that China is struggling to contain outbreaks of bird flu.

However, the U.S. Agriculture Department is proposing that China be allowed to export some processed poultry to the United States.

The chickens themselves could not be produced or slaughtered in China. The birds would have to be grown and slaughtered in America or in one of the few other countries that are allowed to ship their domestic chicken to the United States.

The Chinese products would have to be cooked and shelf-stable, such as canned goods. Cooking kills viruses, including those that cause avian flu, experts say.

Any processing plants in China allowed to export products to the United States also would have to be inspected to ensure they meet the same food-safety standards that U.S. facilities do.

The timing of the proposal "is very odd," said Caroline Smith DeWaal of the Center for Science in the Public Interest, a consumer advocacy group. It would open the border to poultry processed in China "at a time when a lot is not known about avian influenza in China and China is known to have it."

China has reported 29 outbreaks of avian flu this year.

While humans can get the virus from close contact with birds, health officials' biggest fear is that the virus will mutate into a form passed easily from person to person.

It isn't clear when the Chinese exports would start. The Agriculture Department will field public comments on the proposal before moving forward.

The Agriculture Department estimates that less than 2.5 million pounds would be sent to the United States. That is the equivalent of 714,000 chickens, a fraction of the more than 9 billion produced yearly in the United States, according to the National Chicken Council.

Agriculture Department officials said the Chinese competition could force U.S. companies to specialize in products they can produce at lower cost.

Allowing the Chinese products is the price of liberalizing trade, said Richard Lobb of the National Chicken Council.

"Free trade benefits our country," he said. "If this comes as a corollary to it, we just have to deal with it."



Well-known member
Aug 26, 2005
Reaction score
If the chickens are coming from the U.S. and then going to China to be cooked and then shipped back to the U.S. for consumption, why use China to cook these products? Can't business in the U.S. cook without all of the extra cost of sending to China and come out ahead or does the currency hold down of the yuan make that much of a difference?


Well-known member
Jul 16, 2005
Reaction score
You can't fight USDA's "sound science". The 9th Circus said so. If the USDA says it's sound science, then we MUST obey.

Latest posts