I still love my "Temple Tags" made in Temple Texas.
I know with just 25 ( counting bull ) adults and 21 calves I don't have a big herd but the only tag I replaced this year was on the crazy ( #15 ) cow and it was because the ink had worn off. I checked the computer and she was purchased ( and tagged ) in 2003. She is still # 15 but I cut the button shank on her old tag and replaced it in the same hole. Reinking the tag was out of the question unless I wanted to nose snub her but in the chute I used side cutting pliers to cut the shank and replaced the tag in seconds.
Cow #15 showing blank tag ( and muddy head as she is constantly butting the ground! ) Crazy cow!
I did reink # 16 #18 and #20, both #16 and #18 tags were incerted in 2000 and could be read but barely. #20 was tagged in 2006 as a calf ( now in left ear ) and 2007 as a cow.
I tried the "free" Z tags a couple of years ago and lost about 9% within 6 months! I do still have 1 hiefer with a Z tag and it seems to be fading as bad or worse than the Temple tags. I found most of the Z tags around the round bale rings so I'm assuming they get rubbed off there and with the larger base to the buttons the Temple tags seem to stay better.
Yes I have to keep track of both a tag and a button but that is not a problem with me.
They also help me keep track of ancestory in the herd as when a hiefer gets bred the yellow calf tag is moved from her left ear and with a new button goes in her right ear and she gets a new "cow" tag ( red ) in her left ear ( same hole where the calf tag was )
This shows cow #2 was born in 2002 to cow #8
This shows cow #20 out of cow #3 in 2006
I now have several in the herd with yellow tags in the right ear showing who their mother is ( all males get perminent tags in the right ear ) and they seem to fade about the same as the red tags. Easily read for about 5 years then as they come thru the chute I start reinking them. The reink job ( with permenant tag markers ) seems to need a touch up about every 2 to 3 years.
But lost tags are just about none! I do try to make sure to place the tag close to the head and about 2/3 up in the ear ( feel for veins ) but I did the same with the Z tags.
I seem to have more pictures of white cows but I'm down to only 6 Charolis cows and they are not being replaced as they eat to much for the pounds of beef they produce. In about 5 or 6 more years they should all be repalced as the calves out of the much smaller black cows weigh just as much and I can run several more blacks on the same pasture. I proved that to myself when I devided the herd for winter feeding.