• If you are having problems logging in please use the Contact Us in the lower right hand corner of the forum page for assistance.

Another Sad Succession Story

Help Support Ranchers.net:

Cowpuncher

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 10, 2005
Messages
652
Reaction score
0
Location
Southeastern Colorado
In 1937, my parents bought a 1520 acre ranch in Colorado. The price was $10,000. A couple of years later they bought another 160 acres for $2100.

They had five children, two of which were boys. Father was of German ancestry and the tradition was that the land would go to the oldest son. Also, by tradition, girls didn't count much - and they were never even taught to drive.

We were a low cost operation. When I went into the army in 1954, we ran the place with a single team of horses with a couple of pieces of hay equipment.

Before I went into the army, I had convinced my father to sell the ranch to my older brother and me. Older brother had completed his military service and had a couple of years of college under his belt - although he didn't do well. As soon as I told him that I had negotiated for us to buy the ranch, he dropped out of college.

After returning from the military, I returned to the ranch and we decided to buy some equipment. However, brother didn't want to accept a partnership and stonewalled every proposal I made, including buying some real key land in the middle of the ranch. He could not make a decision, mostly because it was my idea.

One day, we were stacking bales and he insisted that only he knew how
to stack them. So I threw the bales on the stack and he put them where they were supposed to go. Only about 30 tons, as I remember. The next morning the stack had collapsed.

So we decided to restack the bales into two stacks. Again, he insisted that he stack them and I would throw them on the stack. By now, his credibility was pretty low so threw the bales at him. That evening, I announced that I was enrolling in the Universityof Colorado and my partnership days were ended.

Some years later, the ranch was sold to my brother. Each of my sisters and I received $4000. By them I had graduated from business school and was working for an oil company.

Older brother then married a single mother of two. This woman was a real whiner (sometimes for good reason). She ran off with a local barber and left brother with her two girls and a son they had themselves. He was ordered to pay alimony. He failed to do so and told the judge that he had heard his ex had remarried. The judge ordered the ranch split into two parcels, His ex sold her part for $150,000.

Brother raised the three kids on the ranch. Our father had passed away and their will said that the assets were to be split among the other four children at my others death. The assets amounted to about $60,000. As an accountant, I managed the assets and when my mother passed away, they amounted to some $400,000.

My brother's son was raised on the ranch. Unfortunately, he was killed in an accident with a New Holland stack wagon at the age of 19.

Brother stayed on the ranch, the girls married and left. After retiring from the oil company, I helped with haying from time to time.

One day, brother"s new wife called and asked if I could help feed the cows as he was sick. I said I would be there in 30 minutes as I live some 30 miles away. When I got to the ranch, I saw the tractor and haywagon crossing the field with no one on it. I sped to the area and found brother laying face down in a snowbank unconscious and not breathing. I rolled him over. I do not know CPR so I just slapped his face half a dozed times and he started breathing again. He was pretty heavy - I put a lasso around his shoulders and drug him into the pickup cab. Rushed to town where I caught a policeman who escorted us to a facility where they had oxygen and EMTs and they took him to the emergency room in an ambulance. He survived the trauma and had a couple of friends feed his cattle for the rest of the year.


He had COPD, cancer, gout, diabetes, melanoma and some less serious maladies. Shortly thereafter, his new wife passed away - she was quite a bit older than him.

He decided to sell the ranch. This was the top of the real estate boom and he eventually got $2.3 million for the ranch. The buyer resold the ranch two days later for $4.7 million. This part of the ranch is now in foreclosure. The part of the ranch that his ex-wife had sold was later sold to John Malone for $1.5 million.

So brother has a cool $2.3 million. Until this point, he had provided nothing for his two adoped daughters and four grand children.

Brother moved to Denver and bought a house. He got mixed up with a couple of women. One of them disappeared, but the other kind of lived with him and went to great lengths to keep all relatives away. His health continued to deteriorate. He decided to give his house to his live-in. In July of 2011, his live-in took him to the county registrars office and they got married. He was 78 and she was 51.

Brother definitely had a mean streak in him and he wanted to totally disinherit his daughters. His live-in said that wouldn't be fair. She knew the will would be contested if his daughters were excluded so $100,000 was left to each of the girls when he died last spring. His new wife made the funeral arrangements - a graveside ceremony at Fort Logan National Cemetery. There wasn't even a decent funeral notice at the funeral.

That is pretty much the story. I liked ranching and eventually bought a ranch in Eastern Colorado where I ran about 750 cows and had a few thousand acres of farm land.

I sold that ranch few years back and paid all the taxes due. I gave each of my kids $1 million dollars. I also setup 529 education accounts for all of my grand kids and I give them help in other ways.

So successionis no simple thing. You never know what someone will do until they are in a position to do it.

Am I bitter - I don't think so. But I am smarter.
 
Wow, what a story. Thank you for sharing, though it must be hard. This is just about printable and put up on the fridge, to have a conversation with loved ones about. Thanks again.
 
Great story, cowpuncher. The thing I have learned is, I am responsible for my life and what is made of it. I can feel sorry for myself and blame my Mom & Dad & brother OR I can step out with honesty and integrity and treat people the right way. God will take care of my life if I let go of the past and look to the future.

"The individual has always had to struggle to keep from being overwhelmed by the tribe. If you try it, you will be lonely often, and sometimes frightened. But no price is too high to pay for the privilege of owning yourself."
Friedrich Nietzsche
 
Makes a person stop and think. A similar story could be told over and over. A different version, perhaps, and different characters but somewhat the same outcome. A part of it is how families work together and try to stick together and try to achieve nearly the same goal.

In my case, I am the one who is left on the home place. I never wanted the home place, but we wanted to keep it together. I am the oldest, my brother just younger then myself worked together a few years, when we came to the fork in the road, he took a different course. Then my youngest brother and I worked together. We purchased more land, holding it as tenants in common.
This brother died in a farm accident, my mother died, leaving me an option to buy the home place. I have done so, and I also have 60% ownership in what my brother and I purchased. I have no family of my own. I wonder what my family thinks of all this, and what I should do.
 
Quite a story that, sadly, has happened on lots of farms and ranches throughout the country. :cry: I applaud you for making the best of the situation you were dealt and having as good attitude. Our family ranch has a set of red gates hanging on the fence that surrounds the place. Behind those gates was sacred ground in my world. It's where i'd blow on Grandpa's coffee, play with my cousins, Hug Grandma after another amazing meal, tell hunting stories and just feel like i was home. Now i am not welcome, (atleast i sure feel that way) and i doubt i will ever walk or ride through those red gates again. :? My cousin and her husband own the land now and are doing their own thing. That thing doesnt include my family. But the way i look at it, is now that my grandparents and uncles have passed away, the house and corrals are just that.....a house and corrals. What i treasure are the people and the memories THEY have in my heart. Lumber and shingles dont count for much without the people. We are building our own memories and traditions on our own place. Hopefully, someday, my grandkids will smile when they remember me and our ranch.

I hope that each of us can find our way as we approach the neccessary evil that comes when ranches pass down to the next generation. We gotta be fair and we gotta base our decisions on love and compassion and lots of thought. Communication is so key too. Good luck as you go through it. And try to smile if you've been through it and it didnt work to swell. Life's way to short to be bitter and hold grudges.

Thanks Cowpuncher, for sharing what must be a tender subject. You sure aint alone in what ya been through.
 
A lot of wisdom and internal fortitude is exhibited in these past posts.
I must say I admire you who aren't bitter and choose
to make the best of life.


We haven't had this kind of situation but I do know what our close neighbors
went through. They have 3 sons. One, the oldest, stayed on the ranch and the place
would have had to be sold if not for him, as the parents had health issues.
The other two sons live in different towns than where the ranch is located. The mother valued a college education over anything. The
oldest was a very smart guy, but college wasn't his thing. He did attend,
but I think he quit before getting a degree. The next son is a veterinarian
with a very successful practice. The youngest son is a teacher. Their mother
was adamant about dividing up the place so that each son got an equal share.
The father didn't agree, but last I knew, the mother won out, which
caused some resentment from the oldest son. He obviously sacrificed an excellent
paying job for ranch wages, no vacation, etc. etc. That was his choice, but I always
thought he deserved more than 1/3 share. This was a wonderful family and as neighbors, could not be beat. We hated
that the ranch came between brothers.
The oldest son did way more than his share of the work and at times
the youngest son might show up with his branding irons so his calves could be branded by someone else while
he went away to play. These situations can be very difficult, to say the least.
 
We haven't had this kind of situation but I do know what our close neighbors
went through. They have 3 sons. One, the oldest, stayed on the ranch and the place
would have had to be sold if not for him, as the parents had health issues.
The other two sons live in different towns than where the ranch is located. The mother valued a college education over anything. The
oldest was a very smart guy, but college wasn't his thing. He did attend,
but I think he quit before getting a degree. The next son is a veterinarian
with a very successful practice. The youngest son is a teacher. Their mother
was adamant about dividing up the place so that each son got an equal share.
The father didn't agree, but last I knew, the mother won out, which
caused some resentment from the oldest son. He obviously sacrificed an excellent
paying job for ranch wages, no vacation, etc. etc. That was his choice, but I always
thought he deserved more than 1/3 share. This was a wonderful family and as neighbors, could not be beat. We hated
that the ranch came between brothers.
The oldest son did way more than his share of the work and at times
the youngest son might show up with his branding irons so his calves could be branded by someone else while
he went away to play. These situations can be very difficult, to say the least.
Things are not always as they appear. My family is no different. H sums it up really well. Memories and history is what made it special. We need to be careful judging others from the outside or someone who feels wronged.
 
I am now within an inch of being 76 years old. I have lived a good life and, I think, I have raised my own family well.

The flip side of the ranch deal is that we had the opportunity to see a lot of the world. I have been in all 50 states and most western European countries. I learned to speak German, some French and we have visited a lot of famous places around the world.

When you work foreign for a big oil company, they pay you a lot. I was able to retire from the business world at age 49. Both of my children have college eductions. My son has three masters degrees and is still working to get a PHD at age 47. He is retired from the Marine Corps where he was a Lt. Col.

I never gave it a lot of thought, but I found Brother was jealous of me. After he bought a house, he did extensive remodeling trying to make his house as good as ours. I never paid any attention to that sort of thing.

When I retired from big oil, we moved back to Colorado and built a house on land we had purchased a few years before. We had owned a house in California. We made good money when it we sold and built our current house free and clear.

We really do look forward, not back. There are a lot fewer miles ahead of us than behind.
 
This topic and the posts are very interesting and some helpful as my brother and I are coming to that fork in the road following our last year working together. I am 30, he is 33, and we worked side by side growing up and since college he has farmed full time and I have worked a full time job plus every weeknight and weekend that I could on the farm. My father is retiring this year, and rather than split the remaining acres, he is renting all to my brother while I have waiting 5 years for an increased opportunity. He wants to make sure the farm can pass to the generation beyond ours and does not want it split. We are cut from the same cloth as far as work ethic but are surely different in other ways. We both are married and have children, but his wife does not work outside the home and he is not marketable or active in our community. It has been frustrating as I have encourage him all along while hoping my own opportunity would grow. I am not a younger son who only shows up now and then to take his share, I have always been here. Between my wife and I we have three jobs and are envolved in 5 civic organizations in our communtiy and have made a life here. I will wish him the best and we will leave much behind, but now we will seek an opportunity in finding someone to work for and an operation to work into.
Thank you for this quote:
"I am responsible for my life and what is made of it. I can feel sorry for myself and blame my Mom & Dad & brother OR I can step out with honesty and integrity and treat people the right way. God will take care of my life if I let go of the past and look to the future."
 
I don't want to steal Cowpuncher's thread so i will start a new one in Coffee Shop.... but i wrote a poem last year about this subject. Thought i might share it with some of ya'll.

http://ranchers.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=61690
 
dakotasky said:
This topic and the posts are very interesting and some helpful as my brother and I are coming to that fork in the road following our last year working together. I am 30, he is 33, and we worked side by side growing up and since college he has farmed full time and I have worked a full time job plus every weeknight and weekend that I could on the farm. My father is retiring this year, and rather than split the remaining acres, he is renting all to my brother while I have waiting 5 years for an increased opportunity. He wants to make sure the farm can pass to the generation beyond ours and does not want it split. We are cut from the same cloth as far as work ethic but are surely different in other ways. We both are married and have children, but his wife does not work outside the home and he is not marketable or active in our community. It has been frustrating as I have encourage him all along while hoping my own opportunity would grow. I am not a younger son who only shows up now and then to take his share, I have always been here. Between my wife and I we have three jobs and are envolved in 5 civic organizations in our communtiy and have made a life here. I will wish him the best and we will leave much behind, but now we will seek an opportunity in finding someone to work for and an operation to work into.
Thank you for this quote:
"I am responsible for my life and what is made of it. I can feel sorry for myself and blame my Mom & Dad & brother OR I can step out with honesty and integrity and treat people the right way. God will take care of my life if I let go of the past and look to the future."
It's commendable that you donate your time to the community, but from an employer and a dad's perspective, too many outside obligations usually cause the farm/ranch work to suffer. I'm not trying to be unkind, but your father may have shown a good deal of mature wisdom in his actions. You have a good attitude and will have a great life, irregardless.
 
Traveler said:
dakotasky said:
This topic and the posts are very interesting and some helpful as my brother and I are coming to that fork in the road following our last year working together. I am 30, he is 33, and we worked side by side growing up and since college he has farmed full time and I have worked a full time job plus every weeknight and weekend that I could on the farm. My father is retiring this year, and rather than split the remaining acres, he is renting all to my brother while I have waiting 5 years for an increased opportunity. He wants to make sure the farm can pass to the generation beyond ours and does not want it split. We are cut from the same cloth as far as work ethic but are surely different in other ways. We both are married and have children, but his wife does not work outside the home and he is not marketable or active in our community. It has been frustrating as I have encourage him all along while hoping my own opportunity would grow. I am not a younger son who only shows up now and then to take his share, I have always been here. Between my wife and I we have three jobs and are envolved in 5 civic organizations in our communtiy and have made a life here. I will wish him the best and we will leave much behind, but now we will seek an opportunity in finding someone to work for and an operation to work into.
Thank you for this quote:
"I am responsible for my life and what is made of it. I can feel sorry for myself and blame my Mom & Dad & brother OR I can step out with honesty and integrity and treat people the right way. God will take care of my life if I let go of the past and look to the future."
It's commendable that you donate your time to the community, but from an employer and a dad's perspective, too many outside obligations usually cause the farm/ranch work to suffer. I'm not trying to be unkind, but your father may have shown a good deal of mature wisdom in his actions. You have a good attitude and will have a great life, irregardless.

Maybe :? But you know they say if you want a job done get a busy man or woman to do it.I was quite busy with a livestock organization for a few years and when home I knew I had to get more done in a shorter time frame.
 
Clarencen, have you ever thought about getting a young family started. My Dad worked for a gentleman for a few years then they offered to lease him the ranch, cows and equipment. He eventually had replaced all of the cows with his own and was offered an opportunity to buy the ranch. He didn't see how to make it work and ended up leasing his cows to someone else and basically retiring. It's too bad the opportunity hadn't presented itself 20 or mor years earlier. It is awful tough to get your feet under you today, much less if you are just getting started. Their are not many opportunities today unless you inherit a ranch from your family. I hope you have an opportunity to bring a young family into your community, who will take care of your place as well as contribute to the local economy and educational system. Without youth in agriculture it is not a very positive future.
 
flyingS said:
Clarencen, have you ever thought about getting a young family started. My Dad worked for a gentleman for a few years then they offered to lease him the ranch, cows and equipment. He eventually had replaced all of the cows with his own and was offered an opportunity to buy the ranch. He didn't see how to make it work and ended up leasing his cows to someone else and basically retiring. It's too bad the opportunity hadn't presented itself 20 or mor years earlier. It is awful tough to get your feet under you today, much less if you are just getting started. Their are not many opportunities today unless you inherit a ranch from your family. I hope you have an opportunity to bring a young family into your community, who will take care of your place as well as contribute to the local economy and educational system. Without youth in agriculture it is not a very positive future.

Both of our sons have left home and have their own lives. The one that is interested in agriculture is married to a lady who tried living in the sticks and didn't like it so having them take over is not in the cards. It is their decision and no problem for either of us to deal with. He is starting out the way we did..... from scratch. (I will add doing well too.)

Having said that, we have talked about partnering with a young couple who desires their own ranch someday. How does one find a couple willing to take the chances and make the sacrifices required to acchieve their goal? It is one thing to wish for and quite another to accomplish an arrangment satisfactory to all involved.
 
My wife and I are on the other side of things. We have been looking for an opportunity where we might walk away from a job with something other than a life of having a job. There are older ranchers in the area that say how they would like to see someone young get started. Althought when it comes time to put their money where their mouth is they sell out. It is hard to approach someone with a proposition, for fear you will offend them or they will think you are a free loader. We have a young family so school location is important as well as being able to spend time together. The other problem is finding someone that truly wants to work with you, not a person that is looking for a hired hand. People seem to have a hard time with someone that has their own thought process and has different or new ideas. I truly believe that you can not argue with success, I also believe that no matter how good you become at something there is always a better way. We do not have a problem with struggling for new beginnings, but they are not worth going broke for. If in the end you can not afford to provide for your family what is really the point.
 
Well I did'nt inherit as much as a pliers and most likely will never and if I do it will be very little.To tell the truth I don't care. My net worth is over double my debt I'm 45 this fall and the only kid that shows any interest is 13 give him 10 years and we'll see if he wants to be a rancher or maybe he'll meet the girl of his dreams and go his own way. A few young guys here who could stand to inherit but by the time the older generation steps aside they'll be 50 years old.Sure glad I did it my way.I'd rather work at Walmart and have 30 cows than wait for my fair share that may never materialize. If you want something bad enough go after it one piece at a time knowone says you have to be top of the pile the first week in the business. I'll be azz deep in debt until they kick dirt in my face If I see some land that I can make pencil I'm going to go after it new machinery not so much.

I don't have a retirement plan I'm doing what I want most days and the lights are on house is warm and my belly's full.I've got 6 great kids and a Wife that would walk thru hell with me everything else is just iceing on the cake.My plan is to help my kids get into ranching if they want but I'm not their gift horse to the easy life. I'll help them get into another business if thats their chooseing but more as a guideance than a financial backer.
 
Denny, I do not disagree with you at all. My wife and I have managed to build a small herd of cows and a tremendous amount of debt, our assests have increased considerably. I don't have problem with working my way up through the ranks, I don't have much now but I have way more than I have ever had in my life. My point is that at some point if the ranching industry wants to sustain a family lifestyle and see their youth return to the agricultural communities, there is going to have to be some incentive. More and more you see some pretty succesful families pass the ranch on and their kids cash it in and some big corporate outfit buys it, thus ending one more family operation. If you want to buy a ranch here you have to be able to compete with big corporations and investers it seems. At some point it will turn around according to history, along with that will probably come some hard times. Unfortunately land leases are the same way. As you know lease rates are ridiculous in our part of the world, other wise Soapweed wouldn't have shipped cattle all the way to you.
 
When I said walk away from a job with something other than just having a job, I don't mean that someone has to give me anything. Although it would be nice to be able to afford to retire or help my kids through college, maybe even take a family vacation or buy some insurance. Once you have done that it would be nice to have something left. I don't feel like there is anything wrong with wanting to better yourself. Some people are sastisfied with just making ends meet and not ever advancing. I had a good friend that raised five kids ranching his entire life, at the age of 80 he had a bad run with prostrate cancer and had to spend some time in the hospital. When he got home they fired him, he had lived in the same house for around 30yrs, the ranch had changed ownership once in the last few years. That was the first job he had ever lost in his life, at 80 yrs old he sat down and cried like a baby. He passed away less than a year later and his kids had to all pitch in to pay for his funeral and burial. He had a great life, he cowboyed ever day. At 80yrs old he had to move in with someone else because he didn't even have enough savings to pay rent. He couldn't have exhisted with out a job if he wanted. I forgot to mention that when the ranch changed hands their was a handshake agreement that Vern would be able to live on the ranch as long as he desired.
 

Latest posts

Top