What are you doing up so early, haymaker?
Sure, I'll compare labels if you like. The labels don't tell the whole story, however. It is INGREDIENTS that make up the difference. Though I will risk sounding like a commercial for Vigortone mineral here, "there are many who copy our tag, while they should copy what we put in the bag." Those quality ingredients result in consistent particle size, which keeps the mineral from getting hard when it gets wet.
Most generally people who who are on a Vigortone mineral program for a year see so much improvement in their cattle that they won't go back to anything else. That 30 lbs. we add to calf weaning weights pretty much seals the deal. Plus the herd health and added conception rates more than pays for the mineral.
What I say is, "We are not a low-cost mineral, we are a performance mineral." Of course we have to be competively priced and we are.
My advice is to try it for a year and see the difference. Or take one group of cattle and put them on it and see the difference in those. I'll guarantee you, there is a difference you can visibly see. Like the shiny haircoat on our cattle. If I can, I will get a picture of our cattle BEFORE we started on Vigortone and post it here. It is nothing short of amazing. Now we have no red tint. If you have black cattle with a RED tint, chances are you are short of copper. Black cattle should be BLACK. Ours weren't. They are now. They weren't healthy, and they are VERY healthy now.
One other thing I would like to mention, our cows get grass and hay. In these dry falls, we have put out Forage Pro starting in September, until we wean the calves. Other than that, they get no other supplement. Just grass. Just hay.
Breaks my heart to see all the protein that is supplemented that is unnecessary. We have taken hay samples all over this country and have yet to find hay that was such poor quality that it needed supplemented when the cattle were fed enough. 10# of a 8% protein hay isn't enough. 10% protein hay fed at 20 to 25# is good enough for most range cattle. Second cutting hay should be fed as a supplement to range cattle, not as a complete feed. 10# of a 20% alfalfa hay with 10% moisture would result in 1.8# of crude protein, that would basically meet their protein requirements. Then whatever else you fed, grass hay, straw, grazing, etc. would add a little more protein and the extra forage would also be necessary in order to meet the dry matter requirements.
PM me when I get back, haymaker, and we'll compare. It is always interesting. We have over 100 mineral products to fit every situation.
Industry leader, that's what we are. Been around over 90 years. (Not me, the mineral~) :wink: