Brad,
On first glance, excellent idea, but brings up another question. Should Agman be compensated???? A lot of what he replies to really can be in response to coffe shop talk vs. trading advice, but I guess I'd have to say at some point, what is in it for him.
I bring this up as a guy who feels fortunate to have contact with several pretty sharp market analysts including he and Doug Berger. Perhaps he gains a lot of new business doing this or perhaps this gives him a level of satisfaction which is why he is as good as he is at what he gets paid for