• If you are having problems logging in please use the Contact Us in the lower right hand corner of the forum page for assistance.

Huh?

Texan

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 10, 2005
Messages
3,234
Location
Texas
They let a buyer weigh cattle at a sale he buys at? :???:

======================================

Cattle buyer pleads guilty to tipping stockyard scales

OXFORD, Ohio -- A cattle buyer who tipped the stockyard scales in his favor pleaded guilty Thursday to reduced charges in Butler Area I Court.

Fernand Lee Allart, 75, of Middletown, Ohio, was accused of placing magnets on scales to reduce the weight of livestock purchased from farmers at Tri-State Livestock on College Corner Pike. Livestock is priced and purchased by the pound.

Allart pleaded guilty to one misdemeanor charge of attempted prohibitions (improper weighing of livestock) and one charge of attempted theft. He also pleaded guilty to a misdemeanor count of misrepresentation of price, a court clerk said.

Allart was arrested in July on felony charges of improper weighing of livestock and theft by deception. He was sentenced Thursday to 180 days on each count, all suspended, and two years of reporting probation for each count. He will pay $1,500 in fines.

Allart also was ordered to pay restitution of $90 to each victim, which was already done. The number of victims was not identified in court records.

Area I Judge Robert Lyons called Allart's actions "disturbing," according to the Hamilton Journal-News.

"You were in a position of trust. People were trusting you to be accurate and you abused that," Lyons said. "I understand your license in Ohio has been terminated, but I don't want you (buying livestock) anywhere."

The stockyard property is owned by George Carmack of Liberty and leased to manager David Hill of College Corner. Carmack said he doesn't want Allart, a man he's known for 50 years, on the premises.

"(Allart) has no reason to be there. How he got involved in weighing I have no idea. He never worked for me and he never weighed when I ran the place. He's an order buyer. He bought for different packers," Carmack said. "He no longer belongs there."

Hill said the criminal activity has hurt the independent stockyards.

"I was unaware it was happening and I wasn't involved in it," Hill said of the scale tampering. "I've still got customers, but it has hurt us. I've been talking to our loyal customers and I'm trying to turn the situation around, get it corrected and turn it into a positive."

Allart was a buyer of cattle for slaughter, while Hill was the feeder cattle buyer. Hill said he's now the buyer for both types.

Allart declined to comment for this story.

The Ohio Department of Agriculture has terminated Allart's livestock license. ODA investigated the livestock market this year after numerous farmers complained about their livestock weights.

ODA inspector Michael Stanton was at the stockyards when he saw Allart place something on the beam scale he was operating to weigh cattle. Upon closer inspection, Stanton discovered a magnet and retrieved it from the scale, according to a copy of a letter to Allart provided by ODA.

Placing a magnet on the left side of the scale beam reduces the weight on a balance beam scale, Butler County deputy auditor Mike Tilton said. In Ohio, the county auditor's office is required to test all scales in the county.

This was the first case of deliberate weight manipulation in Tilton's 30 years with the auditor's office, he said.



http://www.pal-item.com/article/20100814/NEWS01/8140310
 
typical for cattle jockies and sale barn operations in the midwest, this one just got caught, his old age must have gotten to him or he ticked someone off on the inside circle and their revenge was turning him in
 
Yeah, nobody will ever know how many times he did something like that and didn't get caught. I wonder if stuff like that doesn't happen in a lot of the smaller sales. I hear a lot of complaints about weights but most of those people don't really know what their cattle weigh to begin with. Sometimes there are exceptions, though...

I talked to a guy recently that had carried two kill cows to a small salebarn. He penned them early on the day before the sale - before they had really started grazing good. He let them stand in the alley for a little bit while he was doing something else and then weighed them because he had heard a lot of complaints about the weights at that barn.

After weighing them, he turned them out in his pens with water and then hauled them to the sale that afternoon. Tagged them in and told them to feed them overnight for the sale the next day.

They were at the salebarn less than 24 hours before they crossed the scales again. One of them went in weighing a little over 1300 and lost 150 pounds. The other one weighed 1200 and lost 160 pounds - a shrink of over 13%.

When he talked to the market operator, the story he got was that they must have shrunk a lot because the weather was so hot. Or maybe his ranch scales were wrong. Or maybe a combination of the two things. But that there certainly wasn't anything wrong with the scales at the sale because they were "certified."

I told him that I never had seen anything like that. Have any of you ever seen a cow shrink 13% overnight? A cow that wasn't too full the first time she was weighed?
 
A guy down the road from me, an Angus Breeder, used to haul cattle to the sale barn for a lot of people.

Anyway, he got caught swapping some of his poorer cattle for some he was hauling when the guy would tell him to have the salebarn mail his check. (He knew they wouldn't be at the sale if they had it mailed to them.)

USDA came down hard on him but he's still registering those Angus. (Some have horns too.)
 

Latest posts

Back
Top